Thursday, December 08, 2005

He's lovin Angels instead


So Robbie Williams has won his libel trial. By suing, like Tom Cruise before him, he has alerted the world to a story that most people would not have read otherwise.

Since his days in Take That, a band so directly aimed at the gay market they might as well have had pink pound signs tatooed on their well-toned hides, Robbie has played up the ambiguity surrounding his sexuality. This is a man whose first self-penned single I Hope I'm Old Before I Die included the lyric 'Am I Straight or Gay?'. Robbie's sexuality does not concern me, but I find his hypocrisy offensive.

The definition of a libel, which Robbie successfully sued for, is an untrue written statement that discredits somebody and exposes them to contempt, ridicule and hatred.

What makes Robbie's 2-finger gesture to the gay community all the more objectionable is that it was performed in the same week that gay civil unions were made legal in the UK. Many teenage boys and girls have to endure soul destroying bullying at school because they are gay. In our media-saturated world they probably look there for some alleviation of their suffering. Just as it was looking like world might be ready to accomodate same sex relationships a teen idol demonstrates that some people still see homosexuality as something worthy of ridicule, hatred and contempt.



I hope Elton takes back his wedding invitation.

7 Comments:

Blogger Greg said...

I dont like Mr. Williams, I think hes narcissistic and just really annoying, but what hes done has sent out the wrong message. I'm almost sure that he has stated previously he has had homosexual flings - with Guy Chambers, maybe I'm wrong - but its probably just Robbie being jealous because someone else got to reveal something about him before he could get all the publicity.

4:31 PM  
Blogger RG said...

Greg, I do believe you've hit the nail on the head. Yes he has talked about having gay flings before. And he's said things like 'I'm a bender' on TV.

6:04 AM  
Blogger Seán Kenny said...

Good point, Rachel.

Obnoxious publicity-seeking - check.
Dreadful music - check.
Implicit homophobia - check.

Another reason to have contempt for this fool.

8:54 AM  
Blogger Declan Cashin said...

Robbie, 'the lady doth protests too much me thinks'.

Hmm, high profile libel case AND a new album out all the same time. It's strange the coincidences that life throws out.

9:54 AM  
Blogger Mayoman said...

I have to say I like (most of) Mr Williams' music, but I agree with Sean that the fact he took allegations of homosexuality so seriously is a little odd.

Declan might be right - it could just be all about the publicity.

12:28 PM  
Blogger Mayoman said...

Btw, what happened to Elton??

12:31 PM  
Blogger RG said...

Sorry Elton. Technical hitch. I put the photo in wrong place and had to drag it down. Unfortunately EJ got a bit porkier in the process. He'll probably sue me now. If he can turn on scary ol' Madonna for lip synching nobody's safe!

6:03 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home